Knowledge Boundaries

Operational guide for witness scope, public cover, and disclosure. Default to the smallest effective witness circle. If another file implies broader knowledge, treat that implication as suspect until deliberately canonised here.

Current Cover and Final Account

Cover Use

Use the smallest cover that fits the scene:

Context Public presentation
Northern, Wood Elf, Guild, royal, formal-record, port-rumour, written-report Thomas Albrecht is missing/presumed dead in Crown Deep service after the Load Descent Twelve collapse.
Main west port Avoid full names and northern detail; if pressed, Thomas is a human apprentice under Wood Elf guidance.
Eastern local village/highland Thomas is Isha's apprentice. Humans are rare inland, so avoid his full name, northern history, old Guild identity, sealed rank, and Crownholt connection.
Practical trade/work Thomas is useful but junior-presenting; Isha or Kelda often frames terms. Utility work should read as odd apprentice usefulness or Green Road competence.
Trusted final-account circle Green Road remains Thomas, Isha and Kelda in record; Kelda and Erenai hold the immediate aftermath, while family/Elven/crown/deep-dwarf recipients receive bounded versions.

The apprentice cover works because it is close to truth: Isha teaches, guides, corrects, protects, and socially frames Thomas, explaining why a young human travels with a Wood Elf and accepts her lead. Do not make it flawless; sharp locals may notice Thomas is unusually educated, careful with power, or older in manner. It survives because most people have no reason to connect him to a northern death report.

"Apprentice" may carry private playful or tender charge between Thomas and Isha, especially around Isha's dominant streak and Thomas's comfort yielding. Keep this intimate, character-grounded, and limited to when both are present and consenting. Publicly it is social cover, field instruction, magical training, and Wood Elf supervision; privately it may support teasing, correction, permission-language, and chosen submission. It must not become public sexual performance, humiliation, or an erasure of Thomas's agency.

Restricted Facts

Fact Confirmed knowers Scene rule
Holy magic exists Thomas, Isha Vaeloren, Kelda, Aelira Caelithen, Thalen, Sairen Hollowmere, select Wood Elf wardens/test witnesses, relevant High Elf authorities; relevant Irondeep/Great Peak sealed witnesses now know Thomas used witnessed holy force in shield/lance/support contexts; Arliss Fen may suspect Holy Shield after the Crown Deep collapse but lacks confirmed category Guild, temple, caravan, Karrick Gate, Hearthmere, Crownholt, ordinary travel, and non-sealed eastern scenes must not treat it as common. Deep-dwarf records should use restricted witnessed holy force, not broad public theology. Kelda may recognise what she has seen but should not explain it publicly.
Revive / death restoration Before Ch.213: Thomas, Isha, Aelira, Thalen, Sairen and the King Beneath under oath. After Ch.214, Kelda knows Isha previously died/restored and knows she herself died/returned; Erenai witnesses the outcome but not the spell mechanics. Thomas's family, Sereth/Ruvan and restricted Wood Elf leadership receive Kelda's bounded account that Thomas restored her. Still one of the narrowest facts. Public accounts should say Kelda returned or was found alive only if disclosure is deliberate. Do not imply routine resurrection, a repeatable service, or knowledge of the exact continuity mechanism.
Preservation Ring / provisional caretaker status Thomas, Isha, Aelira, Thalen, Caerith, Lorian, Seraine; Kelda later recovers fragments and leaves them with Mira The ring shatters during the final passage. Fragments are family evidence, not a functioning credential or public relic.
Dark fire / black fire Thomas, Isha, Thalen, limited earlier witnesses; Kelda did not directly see the toll-house or red-gate manifestation but may infer an abnormal escape event; King Beneath only by Ch 185 oath-sealed private disclosure Never present as trainable, classified, or public magic. Do not conflate controlled Holy/light combat with dark fire. Thomas and Isha remain cautious even in private. King Beneath's knowledge does not broaden witness scope.
Sealed Rank B confirmation Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Aelira, Thalen, Sairen, restricted Wood Elf test witnesses Obsolete after Thomas privately reaches Rank A, but still important as older sealed paperwork. Do not let public records update to Rank A.
Rank A after Crownholt Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Aelira; King Beneath only by Ch.185 oath-sealed private disclosure; Arliss/Voss/North know only that Thomas changed Still historically important and the highest rank known outside the new western witness circle. Do not retroactively broaden it because Rank S exists.
Rank S after lower-hands rescue Thomas, Isha, Kelda; Erenai directly hears Thomas confirm it in Ch.209 and witnessed the expansion; rescued workers may know only that his healing/power became immense Highest-risk historical rank secret. Aelira, family, crowns, King Beneath, North and ordinary survivors do not automatically know it even after the final account. No public rank record.
Homegate exists Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Thomas's immediate family in limited terms, Aelira, Thalen, Sairen, restricted Wood Elf witnesses who saw arrival/testing context No public teleportation magic exists. Homegate is impossible, civilisation-scale dangerous, and not casual travel. Crownholt does not know Thomas escaped by Homegate.
Crownholt false death Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Thomas's immediate family in limited form, Aelira The North officially believes/records Thomas as missing/presumed dead. His family knew he survived Crown Deep; after Ch.214 they publicly retain the same record while privately knowing only that he later vanished at the Broken Court.
Known Presence message breakthrough Thomas, Isha, Kelda by report, Aelira by briefing Known Presence remains Thomas's spell. Isha does not have it and cannot open/use it. The pushed message was a costly one-way breakthrough after she was outside immediate northern control.
Crown Deep bottom / "what keeps the gate shut" Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Aelira; King Beneath by Ch 185 oath-sealed private disclosure; Ch 195 first-audience witnesses know only the exact warning sentence; Ch 197 sealed/descent witnesses know only bounded category that Crown Deep was old depth/sealed pressure beyond mine/cellar/collapse Highest-risk strategic mystery. Thomas briefly saw black water, chained columns, failing green-gold seals, and something vast beneath Crownholt. The North, Guild, ordinary Wood Elf witnesses, general deep-dwarf process, ordinary dark-elf court, and public city do not know by default.
Isha's idealised Greater Heal restoration Thomas, Isha; inferable only to very narrow trusted witnesses who know enough detail Private bodily and emotional consequence, not a public upgrade or repeatable miracle.
Black Lock intelligence Thomas, Isha, Kelda; Lysa and hidden-spillway survivors have partial information; restricted summaries may reach Aelira/Thalen/Sairen; King Beneath knows broad scope only by Ch 185 oath-sealed private disclosure; Ch 197 sealed/descent witnesses know bounded categories only: old water-road works, counting gates, claimed workers, threshold control, wrong belonging, and something below water Ordinary northern, Crownholt, island, and general dark-elf court scenes should not casually know Lock infrastructure details. Public reports stay incomplete. King Beneath and the dark-elf sealed witnesses do not know everything Green Road saw unless spoken.
Eastern-island destination and local cover Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Aelira, Kelda's Tidefall contacts in cover terms; island locals know only the surface apprentice/friend cover Refuge/investigation move, not public exile or triumph. Aelira's dark-elf letter is private diplomatic material. Use the smaller local cover by default.
Pocket Island existed before Ch.213 Thomas, Isha, Kelda Historical private refuge/testing place. It was never public travel or storage. Its existence remains restricted even after loss; most final-account recipients are told only that Thomas used an unknown passage/continuity answer.
Magic Pocket exists Thomas, Isha, Kelda; other narrow prior witnesses may know limited storage use, but not eastern deep-dwarf authorities Keep private. Deep dwarves have not been shown Magic Pocket and should not infer storage/pocket-space from Thomas's refusal to be held.
King Beneath Ch 185 private examination King Beneath and Thomas only as exact conversation; Isha/Kelda know Thomas went in and returned, but not necessarily all content King-only oath-sealed disclosure includes failed summoning, Ironvein unauthorised host, Rank A/Hero-tier mana, Revive, dark fire, Crown Deep bottom warning, and Black Lock scope. It does not include Homegate, Pocket Island, Magic Pocket, exact escape method, or private pocket/passage mechanics. Not written into general record unless later world-breaking need changes scope.
Demon Lord / three-seal model and final removal Author-facing canon and direct Ch.213 prose. Before the final battle no ordinary witness held the complete model; dark-elf leaders knew their seal protected the world and the King Beneath held bounded lower-sign/seal doctrine. Kelda/Erenai and later recipients know only the bounded aftermath, not Thomas's internal conversation or exact destination mechanism. Historically, three seals held the Demon Lord outside ordinary space; one failed seal permitted leakage while the others prevented emergence. In Ch.213 the First Hand's death collapses the overloaded remaining restraint and Thomas redirects the emerging Demon Lord into lost Pocket Island. The original seals no longer bind it. Keep both the historical model and exact final mechanism restricted rather than common lore.
Dark-elf seal duty Sibling crowns/top leadership; smaller Ch.197-199 sealed group The second seal remains shut. Ch.198 proves the “clean” crescent concealed wear from an erased witness/care office and wrong-side pressure recognised Thomas through a Hero-shaped category. The crowns contain the finding, do not appoint Kelda, and begin consent-based recovery of household custom. No later Rank S/island knowledge.
Nethis / Ch 191-197 dark-elf approach terms Nethis knows Green Road carries Aelira's request and has heard the name Thomas Albrecht; the southern outer court receives Green Road's written conditions and returns written acceptance for first approach; first-audience witnesses know Green Road's accepted terms and that no old name is spent in public record; Ch 197 gives Nethis sealed-witness/descent knowledge because she guides the lower route Nethis does not know Rank A, Homegate, Pocket Island, Magic Pocket, Revive, Crown Deep bottom full scope, exact Black Lock details, or private passage methods. The Levitate moment she witnesses remains describable as bad balance/reaching for a peg, not public spell classification. Green Road's submitted terms include no private questioning of Thomas alone unless he requests it. Nethis is authorised to guide, not compel, and Ch 195-197 confirm she may make clean refusals around unsafe court routes and guide descent without owning Green Road. The court may treat humans as socially lower/curious and demi-humans through inherited labour assumptions, but that social hierarchy does not broaden witness scope or convert Green Road into property, offering, or servant company.
Dark-elf first audience / low crescent chamber Sibling crowns; Nethis; Orren; unnamed High Elf legal officer; unnamed hawk-faced demi-human witness; unnamed dwarf witness; a few unnamed dark-elf witnesses/courtiers They know Aelira's sealed inner request has been opened by the crowns and accepted as serious; Green Road is witness, not offering/asset/petitioner/entertainment; Thomas gives exact Crown Deep warning Do not wake what keeps the gate shut; Thomas cleanly refuses private passage questioning and Rank-category disclosure; Isha blocks death-continuity questioning without naming Revive; Kelda forces no claim through care into record. They do not know Rank A, Homegate, Pocket Island, Magic Pocket, Revive details, full Crown Deep bottom vision, exact Black Lock details, or private passage methods. Later sealed witness expands scope only for the smaller Ch 197 group, not this full first-audience circle.
Dark-elf sealed witness / second-seal outer threshold Sibling crowns; Nethis; unnamed High Elf legal officer; unnamed hawk-faced demi-human witness; unnamed dwarf witness; Lady Thera; Green Road Bounded Ch.197 categories plus Ch.198 wrong-side Hero-category recognition and concealed wear in the vacant crescent. Thomas says not Hero / I am not your Hero without full Hero-System confession. They do not know Rank A/Rank S, private passage methods, Revive or later western island facts.
Magnog / elemental identity King Beneath, Ruvan Deep-Sign, Arveth, old Great Peak priest, Great Peak restricted clerk, Sorrak, Nalka, Green Road after Ch 183; relevant inner deep-dwarf hierarchy by office Public/deep-work language remains deep-heat entity/old heat/deep-heat thing. Elementals are natural forces, not evil/demons. The lesser creatures near the Magnog are not elementals. Current author-facing model links the rise to Demon Lord leakage / distance failure, but do not broaden this to ordinary deep dwarves without deliberate sealed-scene expansion.
Great Peak metal answer Thomas, Isha, Kelda, King Beneath, Ruvan Deep-Sign, Arveth, Great Peak clerk/priest/guards, lower-sign guards, Sorrak, Nalka Witnessed as Form-like metal shaping: pure/smooth metal walls drawn from the Great Peak without structural wound and parted like curtains. It proves frightening mastery/restraint to deep dwarves; it does not reveal Homegate, Pocket Island, Magic Pocket, Rank A, or how Thomas might leave.
Granitethroat passage under Seventh Understep witness Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Maerra Seven-Cut, immediate Seventh Understep gate witnesses; Dorruk Stone-Under-Water and Harra Deep-Set know they gave the approach token They know Kelda presented craft/witness questions, Thomas is publicly Isha's apprentice with a strong shaping spell, and Green Road passed under witness. They do not know Rank A, Holy magic, Homegate, Revive, Pocket Island, Crown Deep bottom, or Aelira's dark-elf letter by default.
Irondeep fall / deep-heat fight direct witnesses Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Sorrak, Nalka, Berrun Directly witnessed divided complete Holy Shields, Slow Fall/Form-assisted survival, healing/support magic, cooling/water/light, and fivefold Holy Lances killing the unnamed deep-heat entity. Berrun knows the witnessed entity and fight, not the later restricted Magnog identity by default.
Irondeep rescue / sealed-transfer recipients Harra Deep-Quench, Varrun, Tharrel; relevant rescue and transfer personnel only within operational need Know the collapse, survivors, dangerous deep-heat entity, extraordinary magic, and bounded sealed reports needed for rescue or escort. Do not assume they know exact spell levels, lance/shield counts, Magnog identity, Great Peak metal shaping, or private escape capabilities unless deliberately briefed.
Great Peak containment direct witnesses Thomas, Isha, Kelda, Sorrak, Nalka, Arveth, Ruvan Deep-Sign, King Beneath, Great Peak restricted clerk/priest, and guards present in the receiving chamber Witnessed Thomas's calm refusal of separation, non-lethal restraint, three layered Holy Shield spheres strengthened with additional mana, and Form drawing smooth metal walls from the Great Peak without structural wound. This does not grant knowledge of the earlier fivefold-lance fight except through a bounded sealed report.
Shared restriction across deep-dwarf witnesses All Irondeep/Great Peak groups above None know Rank A, Homegate, Pocket Island, Magic Pocket, Revive, Crown Deep bottom, Crownholt false death, Aelira's dark-elf letter, or Thomas's possible escape method unless later deliberately disclosed. Exact Magnog identity remains limited to the separate Magnog row above.

| Holy Purge / mass demonic-modification removal | Thomas, Isha, Kelda; cliff-settlement patients/healers including Caron/Erenai; lower-hands survivors | Witnesses know the practical miracle they experienced, not necessarily the spell name, level, Rank S, Revive or Thomas's full system status. Consent/refusal remains part of the account. | | Third-seal island passage station | Green Road and Erenai; cliff settlement knows Erenai guided them to an old station but not every interface message | Station recognises Thomas's maintenance issuance and Erenai's voluntary harm witness. Do not broaden exact route, unanimous-consent carriage, hidden egress or hostile-administration wording casually. | | Third-seal island hostile administration / First Hand | Green Road, Erenai and relevant freed workers; Arlenne/Fenn/Darel know fragmentary prisoner language; later bounded reports reach family/Elven/crown/deep-dwarf circles | Historical canon: the First Hand was the top embodied lackey and hostile administrative claim over an extant boundary. It was destroyed in Ch.213; the claim and command network are now absent. Exact final mechanism remains restricted. | | Pocket Island final use | Reader/direct prose: Thomas uses it as the Demon Lord's one-way prison and loses access. Isha is present; Kelda knew the refuge existed and heard Thomas describe a possible boundary, but does not witness or fully understand the final mechanism. Erenai and later recipients know only that the containment load vanished and Thomas/Isha disappeared. | Do not broaden the exact prison mechanism into public history. Fantasy-world survivors cannot confirm where the Demon Lord went or where Thomas/Isha went. |

Eastern Witness Defaults

For ordinary eastern village, trade, road, or work conversations, Thomas's full name, northern history, rank, Homegate survival, and Crownholt connection should not appear unless the scene is explicitly private, diplomatic, or linked to the northern death report.

Historical Public Witness Scopes Through Chapter 209

Final Witness Scopes Through Chapter 214

Maintenance

When a restricted fact changes witness scope, update this file in the same pass as the relevant characters.md, synopsis.md, timeline.md, or spells.md note.